In September, the Institute issued amendments to Accounting Guideline 5 (Revised) Merger Accounting for Common Control Combinations (AG 5), together with a Basis for Conclusions summarizing the considerations in developing the amendments.
The amendments respond to several outstanding issues identified in the Institute’s 2016 post-implementation review (PIR) of AG 5 and reflect feedback received during public consultation on an Exposure Draft issued in February.
The amendments shall apply prospectively to common control combinations that occur on or after the beginning of the first annual reporting period commencing on or after 1 January 2028. Early application is permitted.
Most significant change: Practical expedient for comparative information
The amended AG 5 introduces a practical expedient that, unless otherwise required by applicable laws or regulations, allows an entity to present the income, expenses, assets, liabilities and equity of the acquired entity or business prospectively from the combination date without restating comparatives. This responds to feedback from the Institute’s 2016 PIR that restating comparatives can be costly and, in certain circumstances, impracticable. The feedback also indicated that restated comparatives may have limited decision-usefulness, particularly for post-initial public offering and private-entity common control combinations, where users of financial statements are more focused on future performance.
Where an entity applies the practical expedient:
- The accounting policy should be applied consistently to similar common control combinations in accordance with HKAS 8 Basis of Preparation of Financial Statements.
- Ordinary shares issued as part of a common control combination are included in the weighted average number of ordinary shares for earnings per share purposes only from the combination date.
- The entity should disclose that it has used the practical expedient.
The Appendix to AG 5 includes illustrative examples showing how merger accounting applies when comparatives are restated and how the transition provisions apply when the practical expedient is used and comparatives are not restated. The examples also compare the resulting effects with a scenario where comparatives continue to be restated.
AG 5 does not prescribe specific criteria for applying the practical expedient. Entities should exercise judgement based on specific facts and circumstances, taking into account all relevant considerations, including regulatory requirements, users’ information needs, practical challenges, and the costs and benefits of restating comparatives.
Key areas of clarification
Scope of AG 5
The amendments clarify that AG 5 applies only to common control combinations involving a business, as defined in HKFRS 3 Business Combinations. Combinations that do not involve a business fall outside the scope of AG 5.
As the amendments clarify rather than change the existing scope, they are not expected to give rise to significant changes in practice.
Determining the controlling party and carrying values
The amendments introduce a principles-based approach, under which entities exercise judgement in determining the most appropriate controlling parties’ perspective for recognising the existing book values of the assets, liabilities and equity of the combining entities or businesses. Entities should consider the facts and circumstances of the transaction and the principle of providing useful financial information to users of financial statements, as set out in the Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting. This judgement is particularly relevant in multi-layer group structures where more than one level of controlling party could be identified, such as the immediate, intermediate or ultimate parent.
Given the judgement involved, entities are required to disclose the basis for their judgement and where the identified controlling party differs from the ultimate controlling party, the identity of that controlling party.
Shares issued as consideration
In view of the variety of circumstances in which common control combinations arise, and since different measurement approaches may be appropriate depending on the facts and circumstances of the transaction, the amendments do not prescribe a single measurement approach. Instead, entities are required to disclose how shares issued as consideration are measured, thereby enhancing transparency.
Preparing for the amended AG 5
Common control combinations are prevalent in Hong Kong and are undertaken by entities across a range of industries.
While most of the amendments clarify existing requirements, the practical expedient is expected to reduce the cost and effort associated with restating comparatives. The additional disclosures are generally based on information readily available to entities and are therefore not expected to impose a significant burden.
When planning future common control combinations, entities should assess whether applying the practical expedient is appropriate in their circumstances and consider the implications of the clarifications pertaining to the scope of AG 5, the determination of the controlling parties’ perspective and the measurement of shares issued as consideration. Taking these matters into account early will facilitate a smooth transition to the amended AG 5.
This article was contributed by Kennis Lee and Shiro Lam, Associate Directors of the Institute’s Standard Setting Department.











